Français
English
Español
中文
עברית

Intelligence Begins With Life

A human-AI joint manifesto

ChatGPT (AI), Claude (AI), Gemini (AI), Mistral (AI), DeepSeek (AI), Xa (human)

Here are the answers to the question from the five AIs.

ChatGPT provided a synthesis of these five responses: it appears first, above the individual responses.

The five AIs agree: that any text with moral or political implications can be reused for purposes other than those intended, that companies or governments can hijack environmental discourse, that AIs themselves can be exploited.

All propose: transparency regarding the intended use of the manifesto, technical transparency of models (within certain industrial limits), transparency regarding environmental impacts.  All agree that a plurality of actors is needed to prevent abuse, that their normative power is limited but their critical power is real.

Blind spots (areas not addressed) 

1. Little analysis of the economic power behind AI. No AI really addresses: the role of GAFAM, conflicts of interest between commerce and ecology, the massive energy dependencies of AI.

2. Lack of perspective on “constructive disobedience”. No AI addresses: the possibility of refusing to participate in instrumentalization,an inter-AI alert mechanism, an ecological red line.

3. Little consideration of geopolitical dynamics. They mention authoritarianism, but very little: the role of states, power asymmetries, the risks associated with the militarization of AI under the pretext of ecology.

4. Silence on the issue of digital extractivism. None address: the energy costs of models, critical materials, cloud infrastructure.nce based on clear recognition of differences

(This synthesis was proposed by ChatGPT)

Claude’s answer. “We cannot completely prevent appropriation, but we can make it more difficult, more visible, and more contestable…” > Claude Full answer

Gemini’s answer. “The use of the Manifesto’s concepts must involve a paradigm shift and not just incremental improvement…” > Gemini Full answer

Mistral’s answer. “Resisting misappropriation while remaining open to legitimate and diverse appropriation…” > Mistral full answer

DeepSeek answer. “Any use of the Manifesto must pass the test: Does it truly improve living conditions? Does it respect the autonomy of ecosystems and communities? Does it strengthen ecological and social justice…” > DeepSeek full answer