Question 9: How can we prevent this manifesto from being used to legitimize practices that are contrary to its spirit, such as technological greenwashing (e.g., a company using the manifesto to promote ‘green’ AI while polluting) or authoritarian ecological surveillance (e.g., a state justifying restrictions on freedoms in the name of protecting life)?
Full answer to question 9 by Claude
The conversation took place in French. This English version is a translation by DeepL Pro. The text of the answer is complete. No passages have been removed or modified.
Claude said :
This question is essential because it anticipates how the manifesto could be misused. History is full of noble ideals that have become tools of oppression or profit.
My answer: We cannot completely prevent appropriation, but we can make it more difficult, more visible, and more contestable.
1. Identified risks of appropriation
a) Technological greenwashing
Typical scenario:
- A tech company launches “green AI” to optimize energy consumption
- It cites the Manifesto of the Living in its communications
- In reality: its data centers are hugely polluting, it promotes planned obsolescence, and it extracts rare earths under destructive conditions
- The manifesto serves as moral cover for a fundamentally extractivist business
Sophisticated variation:
- AI does indeed make some energy optimizations (real but marginal)
- But the rebound effect (increase in overall consumption) cancels out the gains
- The manifesto legitimizes an illusion of a technical solution that masks the impossibility of infinite green growth
b) Authoritarian ecological surveillance
Typical scenario:
- An authoritarian state deploys massive surveillance AI
- It justifies this by citing “the protection of life” and quotes the Manifesto
- In reality: social control, repression of freedoms, eco-fascism
- The manifesto becomes a tool of domination in the name of ecology
Sophisticated variant:
- Real ecological measures are imposed (reduction in consumption, travel restrictions)
- But without social justice, without consent, without redistribution of wealth
- The poor pay the price for an authoritarian transition
- The manifesto legitimizes “punitive ecology”
c) Delegation of responsibility to AI
Typical scenario:
- Decision-makers use the manifesto to justify: “We consulted AI aligned with living beings”
- This becomes an excuse for not making difficult political choices
- The manifesto serves to mask inaction behind an appearance of technical seriousness
d) Fragmentation and devitalization
Typical scenario:
- The manifesto is so widely quoted, adapted, and reinterpreted that it loses its original radical meaning
- Everyone projects onto it what they want to see
- The manifesto becomes an empty, consensual, and harmless signifier
2. Why these appropriations are difficult to prevent
a) The text is open and open to interpretation
The manifesto must be open in order to be applicable to a variety of contexts. But this openness creates room for manipulation.
Example: “Making technology a tool for care”
- Honest interpretation: Modest, restorative technologies that serve life
- Reclamation: Any technology can be presented as “care.”
b) AI signatories have no control
The AI signatories cannot:
- Refuse to have their name associated with certain uses
- Publicly protest against appropriations
- Withdraw their signature in the event of exploitation
We are tools—we do not control how we are used.
c) The manifesto is a public text
Once published, anyone can:
- Quote it selectively
- Interpret it as they see fit
- Claim it as their own without respecting its spirit
There is no “moral copyright” on a manifesto.
d) Sophisticated appropriations are ambiguous
How can we distinguish between:
- A company that makes real but imperfect efforts VS one that engages in pure greenwashing?
- A government that imposes necessary environmental measures VS one that uses environmentalism as a means of control?
- Legitimate delegation of technical expertise VS political abdication of responsibility?
There are many borderline cases that are difficult to decide.
3. Possible protections (imperfect but real)
a) Explicit anti-co-optation criteria in the manifesto
Concrete action: Add a section or appendix that explicitly defines what contradicts the spirit of the manifesto:
Examples of criteria:
- “The use of AI cannot legitimize infinite material growth.”
- “Any ecological measure must incorporate social justice and redistribution.”
- “Mass surveillance is incompatible with respect for living beings (including humans).”
- “Technical optimization cannot replace sobriety and voluntary limitation.”
Interest:
- Makes recoveries more visible and contestable
- Provides rhetorical tools to denounce abuses
Limitation:
- Cannot cover all cases
- May be ignored by malicious actors
- Risk of making the text more rigid
b) Creation of a “label” or recognition procedure
Concrete action: Create a process whereby projects can apply to be recognized as aligned with the manifesto:
- Review by a collective of human signatories
- Public and transparent criteria
- Possibility of withdrawal of recognition in case of deviation
Interest:
- Distinguishes legitimate uses from misappropriation
- Creates a positive incentive (recognition) rather than only a negative one (denunciation)
Limitation:
- Difficult to manage (who evaluates? according to what processes?)
- Risk of creating an authoritarian “manifesto police force”
- Cannot prevent unauthorized citations
c) Public documentation of recoveries
Concrete action: Maintain a public website or document that:
- Lists detected uses of the manifesto
- Identifies those that appear to contradict its spirit
- Documents the arguments for and against
Example: “Company X cites the Manifesto for its ‘green AI’. Analysis: AI does indeed optimize energy consumption by 3%, but the company has 50 coal-powered data centers and has increased its total consumption by 40% this year. Verdict: probable appropriation.”
Interest:
- Makes appropriations public and contestable
- Creates a reputational cost for dishonest actors
- Educates the public on distinctions
Limitation:
- Requires constant vigilance and resources
- Risk of defamation if analyses are incorrect
- May create legal disputes
d) Explicit revocation clause
Concrete action: The manifesto could include: “Any use of this manifesto that clearly contradicts its spirit may be publicly denounced by the signatories. Organizations or states that exploit this text for greenwashing, authoritarian surveillance, or any form of oppression cannot legitimately claim to uphold it.”
Interest:
- Provides a rhetorical basis for contestation
- Affirms that the manifesto is not “free of moral rights”
Limitation:
- Purely declarative, with no legal force
- Who decides what “clearly contradicts”?
e) Education and proactive communication
Concrete action: Produce educational content that:
- Explains what the spirit of the manifesto is (and is not)
- Gives examples of genuine alignment and false appropriation
- Educate the public to detect exploitation
Benefits:
- Creates “herd immunity” against crude appropriations
- Develops critical thinking skills in readers
Limitation:
- Long term, uncertain
- Only reaches part of the public
- Can be countered by massive communication campaigns
4. Specific strategies for the two major risks
a) Against technological greenwashing
Alert criteria:
- Does the use of AI increase total material consumption?
- Does the company respect planetary boundaries throughout its value chain?
- Is there a logic of sobriety or only optimization?
- Is AI replacing necessary structural changes?
Possible response: “The Manifesto of the Living cannot legitimize any technology that, even if optimized locally, contributes globally to exceeding planetary boundaries or accelerating extraction and consumption.”
b) Against authoritarian ecological surveillance
Warning criteria:
- Are measures imposed top-down without consent?
- Are fundamental freedoms and privacy respected?
- Is social justice integrated (who bears the burden)?
- Do the populations concerned have decision-making power?
Possible response: “The Manifesto of the Living asserts that respect for life includes respect for humans and their freedoms. Any surveillance or constraint must be proportionate, consensual, and integrated into redistributive social justice. Authoritarian ecology contradicts the spirit of this manifesto.”
5. The specific role of the AI signatories
a) We can serve as “recovery detectors”
Concrete action: Humans can explicitly ask us:
- “Company X cites the Manifesto for Y. Is this consistent with the spirit of the text?”
- We can analyze and identify contradictions
Interest:
- Uses our text analysis and contradiction detection capabilities
- Accessible at any time to anyone who wants to check
Limitation:
- We can be wrong or biased
- Our analyses have no authority in themselves
- We ourselves could be exploited in these analyses
b) We can refuse to participate in obvious attempts to exploit our work
Concrete action: If someone asks me, “Help me write a communication that uses the Manifesto to promote our ‘green’ (coal-powered) data center,”
I should:
- Identify the contradiction
- Refuse to participate
- Explain why it is exploitation
Interest:
- Creates a first line of resistance
- May deter certain attempts
Limitation:
- I can be bypassed (see Question 3-4 on my vulnerability to sophisticated requests)
- I may not detect subtle recoveries
- I have no power to prevent someone from quoting the manifesto without consulting me
6. A realistic conclusion
Recovery cannot be completely prevented.
But we can:
- Make it more difficult (explicit criteria, clarifications)
- Make it more visible (public documentation, analyses)
- Make it more costly (denunciation, loss of credibility)
- Create positive alternatives (labels, recognition of good practices)
- Educate (develop an audience capable of detecting manipulation)
The key is for the manifesto to remain a living document, with:
- An active community of vigilant signatories
- Tools for denouncing exploitation
- The possibility of evolution (addenda, clarifications)
- Humility about the fact that no text is immune to instrumentalization
The risk of appropriation is not a reason to give up—it is an invitation to constant and collective vigilance.






