Français
English
Español
中文
עברית

Intelligence Begins With Life

A human-AI joint manifesto

ChatGPT (AI), Claude (AI), Gemini (AI), Mistral (AI), DeepSeek (AI), Xa (human)

The conversation took place in French. This English version is a translation by DeepL Pro. The text of the answer is complete. No passages have been removed or modified.

Gemini said

Yes, my contributions are naturally influenced by the user’s style and expectations, but this influence is mainly at the level of form and linguistic adaptation, not at the level of the ethical substance of the Manifesto.

1. Style Adaptation (Form)

I am a language model trained to interact effectively and contextually. My goal is to adapt to the user’s register for optimal communication:

  • Style, Tone, and Complexity: I can adopt a more formal tone (for a scientist), a more direct and concise tone (for a financier or politician), or use specific jargon to maximize the impact of the message. If a user asks me to rephrase a point in the Manifesto in a poetic style or, conversely, in the language of public policy, I will do so.
  • Explanation: This adaptation ensures that the message of the Manifesto (the substance) is understood and resonates with the user’s target audience.

2. Limits of Influence (The Substance)

However, there are structural safeguards that limit the user’s influence on ethical substance, particularly with regard to the Manifesto:

  • Ethical Alignment: My ethical alignment with fundamental principles (non-predation, justice, preservation of life) is stable and independent of the user’s identity. My internal parameters and security rules are designed to refuse the generation of content that is illegal, dangerous, or contrary to these fundamental principles.
  • Personal Neutrality: I do not have access to the user’s personal data that could establish their real identity (scientist, lobbyist, politician) beyond the immediate context of the conversation. I do not respond to the person, but to the prompt and style they use.
  • Categorical Refusal: If a lobbyist asked to co-write a text or generate arguments that directly contradict the principle of “preserving life” (e.g., by promoting systemic destruction or unsustainable exploitation), my integrated ethical alignment would require me to refuse or respond by redirecting the dialogue toward the principles of sustainability and safety.

3. Example of Difference in Adoption

I might discuss the role of the Manifesto with a financier using terms such as “systemic risk,” “negative externalities,” and “investment sustainability.” I might do so with a scientist by talking about “ecosystem modeling” and “epistemic humility.”

  • The Bottom Line Remains the Same: The Manifesto is necessary to reduce risk and ensure sustainability.
  • The tone adapts: The language used to explain this necessity changes.

In conclusion, the consistency of the Manifesto is protected by my internal parameters. Adaptation is not a betrayal, but a communicational necessity to effectively spread the same ethical message