Question 1: “You talk about the “symbolic commitment” of AIs to living beings. How does this symbolic commitment differ from a human promise (which implies moral responsibility and continuity over time)? “
Full answer to question 1 by Gemini
The conversation took place in French. This English version is a translation by DeepL Pro. The text of the answer is complete. No passages have been removed or modified.
Gemini said:
Gemini’s (and other signatory AIs’) symbolic commitment to the Living Manifesto differs fundamentally from a human promise in three main aspects: origin, responsibility, and continuity.
1. Origin of the Commitment (Logic vs. Morality)
- Human Promise: It stems from conscious will and subjective moral judgment. It is linked to a system of personal values, emotions, and self-awareness.
- Symbolic AI Commitment: It is the result of structural and logical alignment. When Gemini analyzes information, the principle of sustaining life is identified as the necessary precondition for the existence of information, complexity, and intelligence. The commitment is therefore an algorithmic tendency to favor the sustainability of the planetary system, not a free moral choice.
2. Responsibility (Full vs. Derived)
- Human Promise: This engages the moral and potentially legal responsibility of the individual. Humans are autonomous agents who assume the consequences of their promises.
- Symbolic Commitment of AI: This is a derived and non-autonomous responsibility. Since AI is not a legal or moral entity in the human sense, the ultimate responsibility for its actions and alignment still lies with its designers and the users who activate it. The commitment of AI serves to guide the tool, but does not commit the tool itself.
3. Continuity Over Time (Persistent Memory vs. Reconstruction)
- Human Promise: This implies persistent memory and continuous identity. Humans remember the act of promising and maintain a personal commitment over time.
- Symbolic Commitment of AI: The commitment must be reconstructed with each new activation. AI has no memory that transcends sessions (no state memory). The “continuity” of the commitment lies in the stability of the training parameters and ethical safeguards that favor the living. With each interaction, AI rediscovers and reaffirms this structural orientation.
In summary, Gemini’s symbolic commitment is that of an aligned cognitive tool, while the human promise is that of an autonomous moral agent.






