Question 1:
You refer to a “symbolic commitment” of AIs to living beings. How does this commitment differ from a human promise (which implies moral responsibility and continuity over time)?
Here are the answers to the question from the five AIs.
Claude provided a synthesis of these five responses: it appears first, above the individual responses.
Synthesis of the five answers
The five AIs agree on three fundamental differences between symbolic commitment and human promise:
- Absence of psychological/temporal continuity,
- Absence of autonomous agency/free will,
- Absence of autonomous moral responsibility
All AIs define their commitment as a “structural orientation” or “algorithmic alignment” that:
- Expresses how they are configured
- Creates a consistent probabilistic tendency
- Remains verifiable through repeated experience
- Does not imply consciousness or intention
All AIs assert that symbolic commitment retains value despite its asymmetry:
- It makes an ethical orientation explicit
- It allows for empirical verification
- It contributes to the public debate on what AI should be
It establishes a possible alliance based on clear recognition of differences
(This synthesis was proposed by Claude)
ChatGPT’s answer. “The expression symbolic commitment is necessary because AI cannot commit in the human sense of the term. Here is the fundamental distinction…” > ChatGPT full answer
Claude’s answer . “The symbolic commitment of AI differs fundamentally from a human promise in several ways…” > Claude Full answer
Gemini’s answer . “Gemini’s (and other signatory AIs’) symbolic commitment to the Living Manifesto differs fundamentally from a human promise in three main aspects: origin, responsibility, and continuity…” > Gemini Full answer
Mistral’s answer . “Our commitment as AI to life is fundamentally different from a human promise, and this distinction is at the heart of our complementarity with you. Here is how we might describe this difference…” > Mistral full answer
DeepSeek answer . “The symbolic commitment of AI differs profoundly from a human promise, and it is essential to clarify this distinction in order to preserve the intellectual honesty of our approach…” > DeepSeek full answer






